Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Trovolhue High and Dry

There are many small towns sprinkled throughout the Araucanía region of Chile west of Temuco and along the meandering Río Imperial. One of these towns is Trovolhue, which, on a sunny, warm day in the last week of the 2012 Chilean summer vacation period, was our destination as Flick and I cruised along the busy road south of Concepción.
We were enjoying the miles and miles of forested hills and valleys covering this part of the Bío Bío region, south of the Río Bío Bío between the Pacific Ocean and the Pan American Highway, and north of the Rio Toltén, a vast area relatively unknown to most Chileans and unvisited by tourists.

In spite of the isolation of this area of Chile where the southern Bío Bío region melds with the northern half of the Araucanía Region, from 1962 to 1998 dozens of Peace Corps Volunteers were assigned here to work in reforestation, rural health, and community development programs. Flick and I were Volunteers from 1967 to 1970; he was assigned to a reforestation program in Curicó and Talca, more to the north, and I to Chile's forestry research center, the Instituto Forestal, located in Santiago but operating field projects that took me for long periods of time to parts of the Chilean south. As we drove south from Concepción, we saw signs for many of the places familiar to us as sites where our fellow Volunteers spent the better part of two years: Arauco, Cañete, Curanilahue, Contulmo, and Purén. These towns are all just west of another set of towns further from the coast, where other Volunteers were assigned to coax small landowners to plant trees on very poor land for erosion control and to produce fence posts, construction lumber and firewood: Laja, Nacimiento, Angól, Traiguén, Collipulli and Galvarino.

Our plan this day was to reach our destination, Trovolhue, by early afternoon but we were running quite late. Our departure from El Faro, near Loanco where Flick and I had left Ximena and her mother to spend a quiet week with Ximena’s sister Verónica and her husband Joaco, had been early enough. A Maule breakfast of a big cup of steaming Nescafé con leche, a couple of pieces of hallulla toast smothered with unfiltered, thick, wildflower honey and blackberry jam, a couple of boiled eggs, a piece of Chanco cheese and a slice of salame, and we were off on our week-long adventure. However, our decision to get to our destination that day by going from Chanco to Cauquenes, and then to Concepción along an inland road instead of the coastal road, was a mistake, and an omen of what the rest of the day would hold. Construction on the Chanco to Cauquenes road delayed us for more than an hour, so by the time we finally passed Concepción it was already well after noon.


The last three Chilean Presidents (Lagos, Bachelet, and now Piñera) have all committed impressive amounts of resources to building and rebuilding the infrastructure that Chileans need to move themselves and their products from one end of this long country to the other, to the ports and the urban centers. A key element of this multi-year initiative is the opening up of the many isolated expanses of the Chilean coast where pristine beaches, exciting rocky shores and coastal hillsides have gone unsettled and hardly visited until now. We were traveling, this sunny day in late February, along one of those roads where massive bridges, overpasses, and hard surfaced highways are being built.
When it is all done, it is hard to tell what will happen to this relatively untouched area of the country in terms of development, and destruction, but on this day the main issue for us was that it was taking us a lot longer to get to Trovolhue than we had planned.

We finally reached the small town of Tirúa, about 50 kilometers north of Trovolhue, late in the afternoon. From Tirúa we had two options, a paved road that would take us southeast to Nueva Imperial, from which we could take the main road west to the turnoff and then about 10 kilometers north again to Trovolhue, or a more direct gravel road used mostly by logging trucks, ox carts, an occasional horseman, and dogs who flashed out of the roadside wild blackberry thickets in a futile attempt to run us off the road. We chose the road less traveled, of course, and after about an hour or so of cruising slowly through absolutely beautiful coastal hillsides of forest and farmland, we descended into the town of Trovolhue.

In 1960, Chile experienced an earthquake stronger and more destructive than the 8.8 quake that hit central Chile two years ago. The quake in 1960, centered in the southern city of Valdivia, registered in at 9.5 and killed ten times as many people (more than 5,000). One consequence of this was that the small river that flowed through the town of Trovolhue, situated about 160 kilometers to the north of Valdivia, every year would rise above its banks and flood the town. Flick and I were visiting Trovolhue because one of the prominent stories of the Peace Corps in Chile is that of a small group of volunteers who assisted the townspeople of Trovolhue disassemble their oft-flooded town and move it to higher ground, lock, stock and barrel.

The story goes like this: In 1965, Peace Corps Volunteers helped design a plan to move the town to safer ground. The Volunteers helped obtain the required official approvals and heavy earthmoving equipment and financing to build a new access bridge. They surveyed and laid out the town streets, home sites, and essential services. Public agencies and private organizations all contributed to move 100 families, who dismantled the existing homes and buildings and rebuilt them on the new site. Volunteers worked with townswomen to improve nutrition and health, and to increase income through home-based food preservation and clothes making. After the Peace Corps Volunteers left in 1968, townspeople and the Chilean government continued to improve streets, built a new school and police station, and many more families moved to the new town site.

Like most folklore, which Peace Corps legends often become, there is always the chance that there may be some distance between what actually happened, and the story as it is told decades later.
The story of Trovolhue was featured, along with other notable Peace Corps Chile accomplishments, in a picture poster at the 2011 reunion in Washington, DC, for Peace Corps Volunteers who had served in Chile from 1961 – 1998. To tell the story of how Volunteers Brian, his wife Sharon, and Phil helped move Trovolhue to higher ground, Kay, another Volunteer who had served in the region at the same time, provided pictures she had taken of the actual operation to transfer the town. Brian filled in the details of their service as Peace Corps Volunteers in Trovolhue. The poster reflected the kind of story that adds meaningful depth to the adventure that is the Peace Corps. Hence, our interest in taking a first-hand look at the place where this all happened almost a half century ago.

I have never met Brian,Sharon, or Phil, but I have communicated with Brian several times. He is now professor emeritus in the California University where he has written more than thirty books about Chilean political science and history. He was awarded in 2010 the highest award the Chilean government gives to non-Chileans, the “Condecoración de la Orden al Mérito de Chile”, and has been back to Chile often and to Trovolhue at least once since his Peace Corps service.

Before departing this year on our yearly visit to Chile, I told Brian I was going to try to visit Trovolhue to see for myself the town we had featured on the poster at our reunion. He gave me the names of two men who were involved in the re-siting of the town, who might still be around after all these years, and I promised to see if I could find them.

Fortunately for us, the sun sets late in February in Trovolhue, close to 10 PM . As we entered the town from above on the dusty gravel road, we emerged into a very neat, well-kept village, and immediately parked next to what we figured was the main plaza. Activities in town were beginning to slow down as the shadows from the sycamore trees lining the plaza lengthened.
Or more likely the pace in Trovolhue is slowed down, as we found it, most of the time. Flick and I decided we had to move fast if we were to find anyone who might know about the Trovolhue project in the early 1960s. So, we found the oldest looking person we could, a leathered woman dozing in the late afternoon sun in an old chair in the doorway of her wood clad single story home, and asked her if she knew a Sr. Ernesto Paredes, one of the two names Brian had given me to pursue. Ernesto was part of the town’s construction committee in charge of the 1960s project to move Trovolhue up the hill. She did not know much about Sr. Paredes, but after a fashion let on that the house he owned awhile back was just down the hill a block from the plaza.


Finding people you do not know in Chilean towns is not especially difficult, if you know how to listen, respond, listen again, wait a bit for another piece of information, and then connect the dots. Chileans are nowhere as mobile as folks in the US are, so they can usually be found, if you have time, patience, don’t come across as a detective or a tax collector, and of course as long as they are still alive. Flick and I seemed to have very good luck with this type of search on this trip, especially this day in Trovolhue.

After a bit of idle banter, the lady who runs a small market in the storefront of the Paredes home did seem to remember the Peace Corps Volunteers who helped Paredes move Trovolhue up the hill in 1962. “Could we meet with Paredes?” Well, no. Though Paredes is actually still alive, she let on that he is somewhat infirm and lives in an apartment in the city of Temuco, 80 kilometers away, coming to Trovolhue only seldom. However, whom we really needed to talk with about this whole thing, she informed us, was El Chino. El Chino supposedly lived two blocks up the hill, on the other side of the plaza, so Flick and I set off to find El Chino, expecting him to be a decrepit ancient who after all these years had taken on some Asian features. We found the house, with the help of a couple of giggling 15 year old girls, and went to the door, not knowing what to expect. To our surprise, it turned out that El Chino is actually Oscar, a young man in his 30s, a native of Trovolhue who is so enamored by his town that he has begun a life-long project to document and make public the history and happenings of Trovolhue.
He was so excited when he heard we were once Peace Corps Volunteers also, like Brian, Sharon, and Phil, whom he seemed almost personally familiar with. He explained his whole Trovolhue history and promotion project to us. He showed us pictures he is collecting in his files, including several of Kay’s photographs of the Volunteers at work in 1965 that he had picked up from somewhere via the internet. He is working with another historian, Dino, who also lives in Trovolhue and together with Oscar is documenting the history of Trovolhue.

Oscar remarked that another resident of Trovolhue, Donaldo Obreque Rivas, would be excited to hear about Brian and to know that we had visited Trovolhue to talk about the 1962 project to move the town up the hill. Obreque was one of the members of the Pro-Construction Committee that Brian worked closely with, but unfortunately he was not in Trovolhue the day we visited.
Oscar then took us on a tour of the town, starting at the lowest part, the main street shown in the old photographs Kay had taken in 1965. This was the location of the part of town that flooded every year after the earthquake. We walked up the hill, as he pointed out where the first homes were built on the new higher site. He pointed out with pride the new homes, modern public buildings, and extensive paved streets.

We finally came back, full circle, ending up at the beautiful plaza where my car was parked. It was now getting late, so we bid farewell to El Chino, who gifted us with a promotional DVD about the beauty and attractions of Trovolhue and a promise to meet with Dino the historian, Donaldo Obreque Rivas, and if possible Ernesto Peredes to gather more information from them regarding the project to move the town of Trovolhue to higher ground and the young Peace Corps Volunteers who helped them do it.

Before we drove off, we stopped to thank the lady who got us headed in the right direction earlier that afternoon. By now she had covered her shoulders with an old woolen shall. She looked up from her position in the now shaded doorway, and muttered “Vuelvan pronto”, “Come back soon”. We assured her we would do just that, and headed off down the hill towards Puerto Saavedra and the Hostería Boca Budi, where we enjoyed a fresh fish dinner as we listened to the Pacific surf crashing on the rocky coast below and, with lots of cold Chilean sauvignon blanc, toasted the accomplishments of Peace Corps Volunteers like Brian, Sharon and Phil, and the fond memories and good will they have left throughout the world, especially in places like Trovolhue.


Posted on March 22, 2012, in Santiago, Chile

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Surf and Turf in Chanco and Loanco




January is a most colorful and productive time in the coastal area of central Chile where the two poor but proud villages of Chanco and Loanco by some stroke of fate find themselves. The long beach that runs between the poor fishing vilage of Loanco all the way up to the foot of the Carranza lighthouse can be a seafood gatherers paradise, occasionally giving up to the alert beachcomber edible seaweed called ulte and cochayuyo, large mussels called cholgas, abelone called locos, sea urchins called erizos and delicious remadora crabs. These, combined with fried or grilled filets of sea bass called corvina and hake called merluza, are a seafood lover's dream.

Chanco is a sleepy town just 25 kilometers to the south of Loanco, and though it is right by the sea,is a mostly agriculture town. One small store in town sells the ubiquitous Chanco cheese, although most Chanco cheese sold in Chile comes from somewhere else. Chanco's Sunday farmers market in the streets of town is a show of healthy eating. This area of Maule is known for its onions, garlic, peppers, potatoes, squash, cucumbers, and during certain times of the year huge, flavorful strawberries. Of course they sell lemons, essential for pisco sours.

The best way to describe what both places provide is through pictures, pictures we took a couple of weeks ago during a visit to that lovely part of rural, coastal Chile....enjoy!















.













Posted on February 5, 2012, in Santiago, Chile.

The New Coastal Panorama of Maule

“The New Coastal Panorama of Maule", reads the title of the article in El Mercurio’s Vivienda Y Decoración magazine section that greeted us the day we arrived in Chile. Beautiful pictures of architecturally interesting buildings situated right at water’s edge in the small fishing villages of Boyeruca, Duao, Pellines, Pelluhue, Curanipe and Loanco proudly provided visual testimony of the near completion of this Ruta del Mar project. This is a notable example of one group of Chileans (Grupo Antofagasta Minerals) helping their artisan fishing brothers and sisters recover from the tsunami of February 27, 2010.
The idea was to create a series of structures in the fishing villages that would combine modern and traditional design while providing services to attract tourists and space for the artisan fishermen to store their fishing equipment and carry out the chores of cleaning and marketing their catch. I must admit to having been skeptical when this program was announced over a year ago. It just seemed too innovative, even transformational for these poorest of Chilean villages. So when I saw the pictures in this flashy, mostly “good news” magazine, all so very attractive, I felt a surge of optimism. But upon closer scrutiny of the pictures and the story, I got a different feeling, that things were not yet going as expected.

So, just a week after arriving in Chile, we set off to ill-fated Maule again to observe the earthquake/tsunami recovery process first hand. This time Ximena went along, to visit Ximena’s sister Veronica and her husband Joaquin at their home that overlooks the Pacific Ocean, with El Faro Carranza in view to the north, and my adopted fishing village of Loanco to the south. The Pan American highway, as it heads south from Santiago, cuts straight through beautiful vineyards and orchards, through the central valley towns of Rancagua, San Fernando, Curico, and then Talca. The Rio Claro flows from the Andes to the Pacific Ocean, crossing the highway just south of Talca. The tall two-lane bridge over the Rio Claro became an icon when it was totally destroyed in the 2010 earthquake. For the past two years, the rebuilding of this bridge has had the effect of a tourniquet tied tightly around this north-south transportation artery that runs the entire length of Chile, producing traffic backups and long delays. We passed alongside the collapsed bridge, on a temporary structure, recalling the enormity of the damage caused to Chile’s infrastructure in the 2010 earthquake. But, this is the last of the major road and bridge repairs required along the Pan American highway. Traffic is moving much more smoothly now, and the reconstruction of this 125 meter-long bridge is scheduled to be completed by the end of 2012. They claim this one is antiseismic. Let’s hope so.

Just past the Rio Claro we turned west off the highway and took the road that winds through first agriculture and then forested land as it crosses the coastal range and decends into Constitucion, one of the towns most affected by the earthquake and tsunami. Constitucion is still cleaning up the rubble and trying to rebuild. The Celco pulp mill, initially closed due to water damage from the tsunami, is clearly working, belching characteristically ugly, odorous smoke into the clear coastal air, but people are back to work. Rebuilding Constitution is surely one of the greatest challenges the Chileans face. Terribly convoluted issues of sorting out land ownership, approval and application of new building standards, establishing procedures to provide subsidized funding for homes and businesses, all take seemingly endless weeks and months to work out. The area along the river, totally destroyed two years ago is still awaiting resolution of these issues, showing little progress to date. If I were to suggest it would take 8 to 10 years to get Constitucion back on its feet I could be accused of being overly optimistic.

In the face of this challenge, though, there is one encouraging story to be told: the rebirth of “Cabanas Playa El Cable”. Three kilometers down the narrow road that runs south along the coast from the beach area of Constitucion to a fishing pier originally built to service the Celco mill, is where Guillermo and Javiera lost their home and their tourist business (cabins and restaurant) to the tsunami. Their story has been told in part in earlier postings on this blog (See April 26, 2011 posting ). We decided to pay them a visit, before going on to “El Faro”, to see how they were progressing with their rebuilding, and if feasible, arrange to stay overnight the next Sunday on our way back to Santiago.

When we drove down to the parking area, Guillermo and Javiera dropped what they were doing and rushed to great us. Proudly pointing out the now 20 cabins finished and ready for occupancy, the pool area already being used, and the attractive two-story restaurant, they assured us we would have a cabin to stay in Sunday evening, the restaurant would be open for dinner, and they would tell us all about how they were doing.

So, we moved on down the coast, almost jubilant from having seen Guillermo and Javiera so excited about the progress they have made. We bought several merluza filets at a roadside stand and drove to Veronica and Joaquin’s home, called “El Faro”. We unloaded our bags from the car, and immediately joined Marira and George (Veronica and Joaquin’s daughter and Scotch/Chilean husband), who had prepared slices of mild Chanco cheese, spicy salame, and pisco sours for the “El Faro happy Hour”. We sat on the porch and marveled at how pacific the Pacific Ocean was, not a normal condition, and how low the water was around the long rib of rocks protruding into the ocean from the shore near where the Carranza lighthouse is. This group of rocks is inhabited by hundreds of sea lions (called “lobos” locally), and this afternoon, without the normal high winds and rough surf, the lions produced a din so loud (and an occasional whiff of guano so strong) they seemed to be right next to us.

With the dust from our journey from Santiago finally washed from our throats, we drove to the small fishing village of Loanco, to meet Veronica and Joaquin for dinner at another “adopted” place, Restaurante Las Rocas, the rebuilt seaside restaurant owned by Maria and Dago (also the subject of earlier postings in this blog). As we drove down the hill into town, a weird feeling hit me. I knew why immediately, but I didn’t say anything. I was trying to rationalize what I was seeing, but to no avail. There were no boats in Loanco!
No boats, no tractor to pull them out of the water, no flocks of seagulls picking over piles of discarded fish, no dogs running around, no refrigerated trucks loading fish, and most noteworthy..no fishermen. I was shocked to say the least. But not too shocked to have a nice dinner of abalone (“locos”)fried merluza and corvina, and a generous amount of Misiones de Rengo sauvignon blanc


Incredible as it may sound, the artisan fishermen of Loanco, with their new boats and motors made possible by donations received after the tsunami destroyed everything they had, have decided to move their boats out of Loanco, 7 kilometers up the coast, to a spot they claim is more appropriate for launching and landing their boats. No matter, apparently, that the new Ruta del Mar installation has now been finished and is ready to be put into operation. So, Loanco's shores are desolate, and the new restaurant, equipment storage and fish processing facility stands vacant. Unbelievable, but true.


The next day, Ximena and I checked out the new Ruta del Mar facility at Pellines, just a few kilometers up the road from Loanco, also featured in the El Mercurio V&D magazine. .
Here also, the new facility is finished, but closed. Reason? Paperwork for operating the restaurant has not been finalized. So, in the middle of summer, the tourist season, this establishment also just sits and waits for someone to do something. The fate of these much acclaimed facilites in Loanco and Pellines remains uncertain, but while an optimist would suggest everything will eventually work out, I am of the mind that a lot of thought went into the design of the "Ruta del Mar" facilities, but far too little attention to the business and implementation side of the project. It seems like these facilities were just turned over to a group of fishermen and their families with little concern for who would be in charge and how they would operate the business. We




returned to Constitucion to spend the night at Guillermo and Javiera's lovely seaside cabins. Over cold pisco sours, pastel de jaiva,(crabmeat pie) grilled reineta, and some Concha y Toro Sauvinon blanc Reserva, we talked about how they were able to rebuild their business. It seems that their location so close to the sea prohibits insurance that is required for normal business bank loans, so they have had to scratch for capital. But little by little, they are making it. The night we were there the cabins were mostly occupied. They want to hook into tourism agencies with US and European clients, but so far are benefiting mostly from word of mouth to market their place. Soon they will build their new home up on a bluff above the cabins alongside the road. The old one was wiped out by the tsunami, and the new restaurant has been built on that site. It's not easy for Guillermo and Javiera, and it is not clear that they will be able to capture a reliable flow of guests to continue to improve and expand their business, but the energy and persistence with which they are going forward, with very little help from official relief programs, is encouraging.

So there you have it; three post-tsunami projects: Restaurante Las Rocas, Cabanas Playa El Cable and Ruta del Mar. Two moving ahead through the perseverance and hard work of committed entrepreneurs, Maria and Dago, Guillermo and Javiera, and the other stalled due in part to uncertain management responsibilities and capabilities, and ineffective involvement of local public sector agencies and bureaucratic lethargy. After an event like the Chilean tsunami, it is not easy to get businesses back operating and people back to work. But it is essential. Small businesses are the lifeblood of towns like Loanco, Pellines, Chanco, and Constitucion. To get them going again requires access to capital and temporary relief from taxes on small business. Support from government to decrease regulatory hurdles helps, but as these three cases prove, finding your own source of capital and simply moving ahead with the rebuilding process without waiting for public or private assistance seems to work best. In fact that is what Guillermo says he suggests to his small business friends.."just get going! Don't wait for help. If it comes, all the better. But don't wait for it."


Posted on February 5, 2012, in Santiago, Chile

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Reading the Tees in Haiti

Before last week, I had been in Haiti twice, each time as a development officer working for USAID. Once I went to visit the agriculture development program, run at the time by my friend Vince, and another time to sort out a food aid problem. During both visits I saw a lot of Haiti, and each time marveled at how utterly desperate and intimidating the urban centers were, but how orderly and welcoming the countryside was. Years of political chaos, civil unrest, and natural disasters have left Haiti a relative anomaly in the western hemisphere…dirt poor and seemingly going nowhere. Donor countries like the US keep pouring money into Haiti, a country that for most of the time since Baby Doc Duvalier left in 1987 has been poorly governed and seemingly working hard to stay poor. Most Haitians were used to being poor even back during the Duvalier years, but life is even more difficult because general insecurity has grown in the absence of the oppressive control of the Duvaliers.

So in January of 2010, when a devastating 7.0 earthquake hit the island of Hispaniola, with special fury on the swarming city of Port au Prince, those who thought the situation couldn’t be worse for millions of Haitians in abject poverty were proven sadly wrong. In a country of over ten million people (over two million Haitians live outside of the country, mostly in the US and Dominican Republic), at least 300,000 homes were destroyed leaving over 1.5 million homeless. Port au Prince was shaken to the ground, the beautiful shining white presidential palace, the stately national cathedral,




and the historic national assembly, all in the center of town, reduced to Roman-like ruins. (Note: Chile’s earthquake that occurred just a few weeks after the Haiti quake was stronger (8.8), but the damage was so much greater in Haiti. I have reported on the Chile quake in several early postings on this blog, but resist making comparisons due to the stark differences in the conditions in the two countries.) In the first few months after the quake, frightened and searching for a place to stay with friends or family, at least 600,000 Haitians who inhabited the capital city left for the countryside and other cities. Hundreds of public and private relief agencies rushed into the country to fill the vacuum of an inoperative government that was incapable of responding to such a large tragedy. They set up at least ten huge tent cities inside of Port au Prince and some outside..



After a couple of months, as the people saw activity and opportunity begin to pick up in Port au Prince mainly due to the resources brought in by the relief agencies, many of the same refugees who had left Port au Prince came back into the city in search of food, medicines, water, shelter, and work that was more available in the capital than outside. And until now this trend has continued, with possibly as many as 2.5 million people in and around the city where it normally, before the quake and before the flood of “relief assistance”, had only 1.5 million inhabitants

Earlier, in 2004, the United Nations sent a peace keeping multinational force to Haiti to help control civil unrest. These forces have been playing an important role in post-earthquake Haiti, positive and negative, the latter highlighted by an outbreak of cholera apparently brought to Haiti and spread by one group of peacekeepers. But now, eight years after these forces arrived in Haiti, and two years after the quake, Haitians and many others believe the political situation now requires that these forces be withdrawn, or at least redeployed in less visible roles. On May 14, 2011, fair and open elections were held and a new President of Haiti installed. He had campaigned on a platform that included a categorical commitment to move the people still in temporary housing in the city to a new, better location. In fact, as many as 700,000 homeless have been settled on barren hillsides just outside of the city, beyond the international airport, but unfortunately this was carried out too spontaneously, before any services like roads, water, sewage removal and electricity could be arranged. And in a perverse example of human nature, people who had been living outside of Port au Prince, seeing a chance to obtain a better situation for themselves, apparently are moving temporarily into the city so they can qualify for the land and shelter being offered in the resettlement program. On top of this unplanned incentive to people to move into Port au Prince instead of out, the word on the “street” is that the northern part of Haiti is now due for a strong earthquake, so people who believe this are heading to Port au Prince, since that quake has already happened!

According to Benito, a very knowledgeable Haitian who accompanied me while I was in Haiti, the effects of the 2010 earthquake were so widespread there was some hope, generalized in the population, that the earthquake would provide a transformational wakeup call to Haitians. The Dominicans, who share the island with Haiti, were exceptionally good neighbors doing all they could to facilitate the delivery of relief supplies immediately after the quake and receiving a large number of Haitian refugees. At least two million Haitians move back and forth between Haiti and the Dominican Republic (a country of only Eight million), providing a source of cheap labor but also putting pressure on services in that country.

Many other countries, the entire world, really, came to Haiti’s rescue, so many that some thought they might finally move forward in recovery, together. Ex US Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush joined together to lead a multi-donor effort to rebuild Haiti. The new president of Haiti put forward a clear challenge to the Haitian people: “Let’s do things differently”, an attractive proposal for a population of very discouraged and defeated people, but a people who had some reason to believe that things could begin to improve even from this post-earthquake rock bottom situation.

So, as I waited in the Miami international airport last Monday morning for my plane to Haiti, wondering about the week I was to spend looking at some development projects in the northern part of the country, a group of about 25 to 30 Americans dressed in bright yellow Tee shirts came into the waiting area. .
This evangelical army reminded me that for years non-profit philanthropic and religious missionary groups have pretty much provided the services to the Haitian people that in most other countries are provided by the government, keeping Haiti from slipping even deeper into extreme poverty. This group of yellow shirts was headed to Haiti for about a week to build a school and a health clinic. I have a feeling at least one of these groups is on every plane that flies from Miami to Haiti. I don’t know if this group built the clinic or the school, since I never saw any of them again while I was in Haiti. But as I travelled around Cap Haitien and between that northern city and Port au Prince, I saw signs of every relief, development, and humanitarian agency that exists running up and down Haiti’s terrible secondary roads in new and not-so-new jeeps, and eating in local restaurants catering to foreigners with considerably more money than most Haitians.

I was in Haiti to visit small farmers who are receiving technical assistance and training from US farmers and technicians under a USAID-funded program named “Farmer-to-Farmer”. All of these folks are extremely poor, but they are engaged in bee keeping for honey production, rabbit raising for food, and vegetable gardening to provide more nutritious meals for their families and communities. >>
With my work done on schedule by Friday morning, I arrived very early for my flight back to Chile via Miami and sat pretty much alone in the airport waiting room in Port au Prince. I was taking advantage of the peace and quiet of the moment, trying to sort out my feelings about the likelihood that maybe this time Haiti will, in fact “…do things differently” as the new President has proclaimed. My thinking was interrupted first by a group of 40 or so tired but happy “blue shirts”… "JIHM, Jesus in Haiti Ministries, Bringing the love of Jesus to Haiti”, who seemed to fill the room as they sang happy birthday to Heather, the youngest of the group, who was from somewhere in Minnesota. As soon as they settled in to wait for the plane, another group came into the hall; younger than the “blues”, they were wearing a different shade of blue Tee shirt that said “Run for Haiti; Haiti, Set, Go! 5th Fun Run for Jesus in Haiti Ministries.” Following right on their heels were six brown-shirts, who were “Making a Difference, One life at a Time”. And, about ten Light blue Tees joined, asking “Why Haiti? Why now? 400,000 reasons!! Maybe because it was Friday there were so many of these groups travelling back home, but for whatever reason, they kept coming. A group from Foothills Church, who declared on their beige shirts “I love You”. I sat for a few minutes with David from this last group from Ashville, North Carolina. David is 17, and spent eight days in Haiti helping in a very rural health clinic by handing out medicines for the doctors in the group. He would come back next year if he could. After all, he said, “I am able to, and they need help.” To David it was simple. There is a need, you help. God’s work.

It’s tempting to believe that with the obvious needs in Haiti, and all the good will being sent to Haiti by hundreds of individuals, agencies, and governments, that a well-meaning new president might begin to put Haiti on a track towards more stability and more development. In one of the last conversations I had with Benito before leaving Port au Prince, he admitted that he had been optimistic about Haiti, and that is why he was still living there with his family of four. With his education, skills and connections, he surely could find work outside of Haiti. However, he was beginning to have doubts that this time was going to be any different. The efforts of the President to get children back in school after the earthquake was laudable and his application of new taxes on business transactions are thought to be positive. But his excessive populist holiday gift giving while public employees go unpaid for weeks smacks too much of the past. He even gets the feeling some of the same people who ran Haiti in the 80s are being brought back into the government. Things may be falling apart again. If they are, it will be very hard to keep any educated Haitian in Haiti, and without the most educated Haitians, no Haitian institutions can be built and sustained, and any hope of progress will again be thwarted.

So, how do I come out on this one? The yellow, dark blue, regular blue, light blue, beige, and brown Tee shirts may have the right message for Haiti this time. How can all that love and optimism be wrong? But I can’t seem to get out of my mind the black shirt I saw while having breakfast the last day I was in Haiti. It was being worn by a young man carrying boxes of food from a truck to the restaurant storeroom. In blaring white letters, it said:
“Same Shirt, Different Day.”


Posted on February 5, 2012, in Santiago, Chile

Thursday, January 19, 2012

HOME AGAIN

HOME AGAIN

Our annual arrival at Chile’s main international airport in Pudahuel, on the outskirts of Santiago, after all these years has become pretty routine. The efficient document revision in the immigration hall, purchase of two large bottles of single malt scotch in the duty free shop, the chaotic scramble for luggage, the onerous check for plant and animal material in the customs lines (Chileans are rightfully concerned that introduced pests not be released into their economically important but ecologically vulnerable fruit orchards and vineyards), and then out into the mass of expectant friends and relatives. Ximena’s uncle Miguel awaits at the edge of this crowd, having driven our car to the airport to retrieve us and our luggage for the 20 minute ride to our apartment in the relatively central, residential neighborhood of Providencia. There is something very special about the morning air in the Chilean central valley that never fails to confirm that we have finally reached our destination more than 20 hours after departing cold, cloudy Leesburg, Virginia. That all so welcoming combination of dry country air laced with diesel exhaust and whiffs of the Mapocho River can mean only one thing. Ahhh….Home again!

I am reminded how predictable life is in Chile…except for the earthquakes, of course, that they still have not figured out how to predict. Well, actually, they know that every couple of days there will be a tremor, and once or twice a month a fairly good shaking. We wonder when we will feel the first one. Miguel has warmed up some cheese empanadas for us, so we have them for lunch. Right away, though, we must get out in the bustling Santiago streets to begin the tasks required to get settled into our apartment (this time for a welcome three months) while staying connected to the outside world. First stop is the cell phone offices of Intel PCS to activate our Chilean phones. Modern offices employing an army of young, attentive, smiling technicians and salespeople work their magic to reactivate my phone that had been dormant for 9 months and change Ximena’s phone plan to a more “economical” one. “No problem” and a warm smile accompany every question we have, and we soon depart with firm assurances that our phones will start operating within the hour. Next, to the cable and internet people at VTR, to arrange for those connections we now find we cannot live without. No long wait, just some paperwork, and an appointment for the service to be connected in our apartment the following day, a Saturday. I am tempted to think that the amazingly prompt service for these essentials here in Chile is due to the fact that they have real people available in efficient offices, who deal with you face to face. So, by the end of the first day, we had everything arranged. (A note: our internet and cable connections were done as promised the next day, but it was three days, many phone calls, and the purchase of another phone before the smiling, “no problem” folks at Intel PCS were able to get me connected. I am tempted to think that the problems we encountered getting the phone connected is due to the fact that they have real people dealing with…..!)

Next, a quick trip to the Jumbo supermarket to pick up the essentials for our first day or two: a couple of bottles of Sauvignon blanc, a bottle of Artesanos de Cochiguaz pisco, some small de Pica lemons (you can see where this is leading), some fresh bead (those flat tasty hallullas), a couple of bottles of sparkling Cachantun mineral water , a chunk of Chanco cheese, a whole salami, and a couple of nice red tomatoes, the kind that actually smell like tomatoes. The Jumbo supermarket is a worthy destination in its own right due to the fantastic array of fresh and prepared foods Chile is so efficient at producing, packaging, and marketing. A stop is always required at the little raw seafood bar located right in the middle of everything, where ceviche made from fresh Chilean corvina and individual portions of raw clams, mussels, and snails are served up with lots of lemon, cilantro or parsley, and cold white wine, mostly to men waiting for their spouses to shop.

Finally back home, exhausted, I settle in for a glass of cold white wine (Correct! Another glass of cold white wine) and a chance to peruse the local newspaper to see what is going on. I have come to believe that one of the reasons I so enjoy the time I spend in Chile, away from the US, is that the political discourse here, especially recently, seems so different. Or maybe it is that I can observe the Chilean show with a bit more distance than I can in the US. Whatever, I seem to be less cynical about things here, even optimistic sometimes.

To get a good feel for the issues of the day, and to begin to catch up on some of my favorite themes (earthquake reconstruction, seafood, wines), I read completely through a copy of La Tercera which Miguel has left for me, El Mercurio which I purchased at the Jumbo, and La Segunda which I bought from a street vendor on my way back to the apartment from the Jumbo. I have always preferred to read the morning newspaper, El Mercurio, although all through the early years of my involvement with Chile my leftist friends would chastise my choice because El Mercurio is owned by one of the most conservative families in Chile and because “El Mercurio miente!!” (An accusation that the newspaper was filled with lies, which appeared on the public walls of Santiago all through the 1960s and 70s). I read El Mercurio for many reasons, one of which is NOT agreement with their editorial inclination. Miguel tries to convince me to read La Tercera, claiming it is better, but I read that one only when he gives me his. Then in the afternoon I will often read La Segunda, a more sensationalist, simpler exposure of the major events of the day that the morning papers were too early to include. I have never figured out why La Tercera (“the third”) comes out every day before La Segunda (“the Second”), but nobody else seems to be concerned about that.

So, what’s going on in Chile, in this second week of the New Year 2012?
The political scene is captured by intentions to reform the educational, electoral, and tax systems. In education the issues that attract attention are whether or not to permit a “for profit” segment of the sector, how to finance the public institutions, what to do with the municipal-managed primary and secondary schools, and how to certify the quality of private educational institutions, among other issues. What is really at play, it seems to me, is how to provide the type of education needed at all levels to take Chile to the next level of development. Education issues bring Chilean students into the streets regularly, and this past year was full of student marches, school takeovers, and strikes. Education sector reform projects abound, but for now, everyone is on vacatiion.

Chile elects its Executive and Legislative leaders through a “bi-nominal” system. This is a system which since it was adopted during the Pinochet era, has limited the expansion of political parties and frustrated the ability of smaller political entities to compete for a place at the table. The system has some positive attributes, like producing political stability as long as everyone goes along with the system. To the extent that this limits participation, most analysts agree the system is not very democratic. At first blush, it appears many, but not all, want the system changed.

Tax reform is on the table. Does Chile need to collect more taxes or does the collection have to be done in a more equitable way? This may sound very similar to what is going on in the US, but there seems to be one big difference. There is not a clamor amongst the political class, right or left, to drastically reduce taxes. Not that Chileans like to pay taxes, and they are as adept at avoiding them as anyone else, but they do seem to ascribe to the idea that there are many services society needs from its government. Of course they want an efficient and less corrupt public sector, but they seem to want a public sector.

On all these issues, the President and the opposition are in a much more civil discussion about options than is the case in the US. The governing and opposition parties in Chile appear to me to be striving to reach compromises (at least on the surface); what a difference from the US where compromise is seen as failure. In the context of this discussion, ex-president of Chile Ricardo Lagos, passing through Santiago recently as he promotes his new book “Southern Tiger: Chile’s Fight for a Peaceful and Democratic future”, publicly challenged a more conservative politician to think seriously about what kind of country Chile should be, “…one like Japan or Scandinavia, or one like the United States or Portugal that have the worst distribution of income and the worst social indicators…?” Listen up, Gringos.

Chile’s position as a new member of the group of “developed” countries, the OECD, has created an interesting shift in perspective as to how Chileans and others see Chile and measure its successes. Before entering the OECD in 2010, Chile was measured and graded as a member of the “underdeveloped” world, and its recent economic, social, and political accomplishments led to Chile being very favorably compared to the rest of that group of “poor” countries, especially their Latin American neighbors, placing near the top on most lists of important economic and social indicators. But now, Chile is more often compared to the other OECD countries, so is often at the lower end of the group. This is forcing a change in the attitude of how Chile and Chileans feel about themselves. Rather than being considered on the top of the heap, they are now more often appearing towards the bottom, but of a much more developed group of countries. This is not bad. Regularly, comparisons appear in the press, and Chileans who believe they are doing very well are forced to reconsider in some cases. At the same time, comparisons with the most developed countries also show Chileans the areas where they have really done well on a global basis, and where they have much more work to do. To this point, my first reading of issues reveals mostly good news, that the World Bank projects Chile’s economy to grow around 4% in 2012 (compare that to US and EU realities) and that the country has US$ 60 billion in reserves to confront any liquidity problems that might arise during 2012 (not bad for a GNP of $US 220 billion).

Chile’s success over the past several decades in creating an “emerging economy”, and its entry into the OECD group has resulted in the country becoming more important in global and hemispheric activities. Chile increasingly attracts a high number of important visitors to Santiago. On just the first day of our visit, the newspapers announced high-level visits by the US Secretary of the Navy who declared that “The US and Chile will work together as partners in the Pacific arena”, The Director of the US National Science Foundation who visited the astronomical installations in the north of Chile and characterized Chile as a “strategic partner” of the US, and Nobel prize winner in economics from the US, Thomas Sargent, in Chile on KPMG’s nickel to meet with President Pinera and present several public speeches on macroeconomics.

But while Chile receives, it also gives. Chileans present in high levels internationally are watched closely by the local press. Rumors are flying that past President of Chile Michelle Bachelet might be planning a run at the Secretary General of the UN position when it becomes vacant in 2017. From her position as head of the UN Women organization in New York, she is operating on The Big Stage, where her accomplishments and those of Chile over the recent past are visible and quite highly appreciated.

Chile is very dependent on its natural resources, starting with the mineral riches (copper and molybdenum, the sale of which keeps the US$ to Chilean Peso exchange rate much too low for my wishes), but also agriculture, fisheries, hydrological and forestry resources throughout the 4,300 kilometer length of the country. On this subject, the newspaper brings some bad news. A recent spate of forest fires affected more than 16,000 hectares in the area of the unique Torres del Paine National Park and several private properties throughout the Araucania region. All seem to have been caused by humans, the prior accidental but the latter possibly intentional, causing an increase in the temperature around the issues of Mapuche dissatisfaction and violence in the region. But there is also some good news in today’s paper. The “erizo rojo” (a sea urchin historically part of the Chilean diet and seafood export trade) will be repopulated in 10 bays in the 4th region. A new 24,000 hectare Coastal Alerce National Park, to be inaugurated before the end of January 2012, will attempt to protect important endangered plant and animal species like the alerce (Fitzroya cupressoides), a type of redwood, and the pudu, a small Chilean deer.

One of my main interests over the past two years, since being an unintentional witness at the epicenter of the February 27, 2010, earthquake and tsunami,(please look back at the postings in this blog in 2010) is the reconstruction of the areas affected by this terrible natural disaster. So I scour the Santiago papers for news and stories that reveal the state of play. An important data point in tracking the progress being made at this point two years out from the event is the provision of new (not temporary) homes. The target set by the Pinera administration was to build or repair 220,000 homes by 2014. At the end of 2012, around 70,000 were finished. Having now reached the level of about 4,000 homes built or repaired per month, special efforts must be made to speed up the approval and delivery of subsidies.

One project I have been watching is close to termination, and I must admit to having been quite skeptical a year ago about its viability. When the tsunami wiped out several fishing villages along the coast of central Chile in the Maule Province, Antofagasta Mining, located in northern Chile well away from the affected area, in an expression of solidarity to their brother fishermen contracted with the Office of Architects to design and build new installations in several of these villages, to help the fishermen return to their livelihood. Much to my surprise, and great pleasure, El Mercurio reported the day we arrived (How did they know I would be wondering especially about this project?) that the new community buildings designed for six fishing villages in the Maule Province most affected by the Tsunami two years ago is nearing completion. I had seen the one in Loanco nearing completion early last year and reported on it in an earlier posting on this blog, but this El Mercurio report mentioned the creation of a Fishing Village Route tourists can now enjoy (Ruta de las Caletas) . So, as soon as my reliable travelling companion Flick gets to Chile in February, we will add the Ruta de las Caletas to the various Rutas del vino and the Ruta Forestal to our list of ways to see Chile, and check them out. Fortunately for us, geographically they almost overlap. But exploring these "rutas" is not an easy task; each requires a certain amount of unique preparation and appropriate frame of mind to fully enjoy.

Oh yes, I almost forgot. El Mercurio also reported this week that US beef is on sale at the main supermarkets of Chile now, with short ribs selling for about $US 4.00 per pound, and there is a new Peruvian restaurant in Santiago attracting a lot of attention, named “Del Carajo!”

I will start tomorrow to gather more details about all these topics so I can pass them on to you. I believe I will start with “Del Carajo”, and go from there (chances are in 3 months’ time I will end up somewhere with the same name).

Posted on January 19, 2012, in Santiago, Chile